Most “GEO Strategies” Are Just SEO Wearing a Tuxedo

Most “GEO Strategies” Are Just SEO Wearing a Tuxedo

Recently I was helping a friend with a 70-slide pitch deck. Every third sentence had a word like ‘AI-powered’, ‘AI-enabled’, ‘AI-fuelled’. I asked him not to throw these words on clients’ faces like that, but he said that’s what they like.

Everyone in this industry dreams of a client who actually reads the fine print before signing off on a strategy. But let’s face it, most just want to hear “AI-powered” in the first sentence and “guaranteed citations” by the third. If you’re the one who has to explain why an llms.txt (still struggling with schema? drop it) file isn’t a magic spell, take a breath. This one’s for you.

Here’s what nobody puts in the pitch deck: GEO isn’t the problem. The circus around it is. We’ve seen this movie before with “200 Google ranking factors”, a document somebody at Google wrote (or not), treated like scripture because enough people repeated it with a straight face. Same script, new clothes, better production values this time.

So, someone actually sat down and fact-checked 13 of the most repeated GEO claims against real evidence; Google’s own guidance, peer-reviewed studies, controlled experiments. Not vibes and definitely not a LinkedIn carousel (no offence to self-acclaimed Gurus). Here’s what survived.

1. SEO first, GEO on top: Mostly true, but there’s a catch nobody mentions: ranking well no longer guarantees you get cited. Being #1 on Google used to mean something. Now it just means you’re eligible to be politely skipped over. Sounds bad but true.

2. Just unblock every AI bot: Right idea, sloppy homework. Turns out GPTBot and OAI-SearchBot do completely different jobs. Block the wrong one and you’ve solved nothing, but you’ll feel very productive doing it.

3. Write your answer in exactly 40–60 words, near the top: The instinct is fine. The number is imaginary. Nobody has ever recorded where it came from. It just sounds specific enough that people stopped questioning it.

4. Chop your content into bite-sized chunks: Google has said, directly, that this doesn’t matter. And yet there are agencies out there charging good money to turn a perfectly good article into confetti. Is it unethical? I don’t know but definitely unproductive.

5. Pack in stats, quotes, citations: There’s a real study behind this one (which is rare). Problem is, it measured something much narrower (not explaining the limitation, find it on internet) than what everyone’s now selling it as. Handy how that detail never makes the slide and probably never will.

6. Stack every schema type you can find: Tested properly, it made no meaningful difference to AI citations (People in past fought with me to replace deployed schema with their ‘AI-powered’ schema, made me laugh). The sites that use it well also happen to do everything else well. That’s not causation, that’s just a good student handing in neat homework.

7. Build out FAQ sections with FAQ schema: The number everyone quotes for this has never been traced back to an actual source. It’s been repeated so many times it now sounds like fact. Also, (inconvenient detail) the feature it was built for doesn’t even exist on Google anymore.

8. Publish an llms.txt file: Most sites that bother end up with zero AI traffic to it. Nobody’s coming to read your homework. It just sits there, quietly unread, like a New Year’s resolution by February or may be 3rd week of January. Wise to mention that Ahrefs found 97% of llms.txt files in its 137K-domain dataset received zero requests during May 2026.

9. Show off E-E-A-T with author bios and credentials: The underlying idea is sound. The specific percentages people quote trace back through two or three other people quoting each other, and somewhere at the bottom of that chain is a study that ironically isn’t there.

10. Earn mentions, not just backlinks: This one actually holds up better than the rest. I have been emphasising this to all PR teams. Real, strong pattern, just no proof of direct cause. Still, if you’re only doing one thing this quarter, this is the one worth your time.

11. Refresh your content on a strict schedule: More than anything, it’s common sense, come on, makes sense for anything time-sensitive. Freshness should be query-dependent rather than scheduled mechanically. The specific numbers thrown around, weekly refreshes, expiry dates, don’t trace back to anything real. Somebody needed a deliverable and picked a number that sounded confident.

12. Track your AI search ranking: Many agencies are crazy behind it and make fool out of clients too. Trust me, there isn’t really such a thing (there isn’t one stable, deterministic AI ranking equivalent to SERP position). Ask the same question twice and you’ll likely get two different answers. What does stay consistent is which brands show up at all, track that instead, the way you’d run a survey, not a leaderboard.

13. Every AI engine needs its own content approach: No AI company has ever published a style guide for this (at least till the time I am writing this blog). Every “this engine prefers X” table out there is someone staring at outputs and turning a wild guess into a rule. However, Google has published an optimisation guide, and OpenAI publishes guidance for publishers.

So, what’s actually left standing?

Nothing glamorous that sounds AI-ish, unfortunately. Be easy to find. Say something worth repeating. Keep your facts the same everywhere they appear. Get talked about for real reasons. And measure your visibility properly instead of chasing a single number that doesn’t really exist.

None of that fits neatly on a slide with a bold title and a rocket-ship graphic. Which is exactly why the invented version keeps winning the pitch, it’s simply easier to sell than the honest one. In this world (hoping there are other worlds too), in front of the client, fancy promises, jazzy frameworks and assurances (given in an American accent) will always win over simple facts and nuances?

Credit: “…fact-checked 13 of the most repeated GEO claims. Shoutout to Gianluca Fiorelli for actually doing the homework the rest of us just repeat.”

Have a project in mind?

LET'S WORK TOGETHER

Design and Developed by Buffalo Soldiers

© 2026. All rights reserved @ChandanSharma

Books by Chandan Sharma
Read my books at chandansharmabooks.com

Hindi poetry and practical AI guides, available as eBooks you can read on your phone, tablet or computer. Pick a book, get your copy and start reading today.

Browse the books →